We often speak proudly of raising the next generation to become confident, capable and independent thinkers. We encourage children to be curious, express themselves and develop their own identities. However, there is an interesting contradiction in how we sometimes approach this. We celebrate their independence until it begins to challenge our expectations. Suddenly, the very qualities we hoped to nurture can become the ones we find most difficult to accommodate.
This month’s Children and Family Forum in Muscat, held under the theme “Every child is an ambassador", offered a timely reminder of the importance of recognising children’s voices, talents and potential. It is a powerful message that invites us to reflect on the future we are preparing our children for. However, it also invites us to look a little closer at what happens long before they become contributing members of society, within the everyday interactions of family life.
Consider how frequently children are encouraged to think for themselves, only to discover that certain answers are more acceptable than others. A child questions a family rule and is told not to argue. Another expresses discomfort with hugging a relative, and is reminded to be polite. A teenager disagrees with a parent’s opinion and is accused of having an attitude. None of these responses necessarily come from a place of ill intention. Often, they reflect the values, beliefs and expectations we inherited ourselves.
Somewhere along the way, however, children can begin to learn that having a voice is acceptable, provided it doesn’t create discomfort for the adults around them. They become skilled at reading reactions, anticipating expectations and adjusting their responses accordingly. What looks like cooperation may sometimes be an attempt to preserve connection, avoid conflict, or secure approval. The question then becomes whether we are developing independent thinkers or simply children who have become very good at knowing what we want to hear.
Of course, encouraging children to express themselves doesn’t mean abandoning boundaries or allowing every decision to become a negotiation. Children need guidance, structure and adults who can confidently hold limits. Yet, there is a fundamental difference between teaching children respect and teaching them obedience. A child can hold a different opinion without being disrespectful. They can feel disappointed without being ungrateful, question a decision without being defiant, and have a different perspective without rejecting the values of their family.
Perhaps the greater challenge rests in recognising what their independence brings up within us. When a child questions our decision, do we hear curiosity or criticism? When they say “no”, do we experience it as information or a threat to our authority? Our reactions often reveal as much about our own relationship with control, respect and disagreement as they do about the child’s behaviour. Learning to tolerate a different opinion without immediately needing to correct it is a skill many adults are still developing.
These seemingly ordinary exchanges carry significance far beyond childhood. We cannot reasonably expect young people to become confident decision makers, establish healthy boundaries or challenge harmful behaviour, if their early experiences repeatedly taught them that disagreement comes at the cost of being accepted. The ability to think independently develops through opportunities to practise, including the freedom to make mistakes, reconsider opinions and occasionally arrive at conclusions different from our own.
As we celebrate children’s potential, perhaps we should consider whether we are equally committed to making room for their individuality. After all, raising a child who knows how to follow instructions is one thing. Raising one who knows when to question them is quite another. If we teach children that respect means never questioning authority, how will they recognise the moments when authority deserves to be questioned?
Oman Observer is now on the WhatsApp channel. Click here
