Saturday, November 21, 2026 | Jumada al-akhirah 10, 1448 H
broken clouds
weather
OMAN
26°C / 26°C
EDITOR IN CHIEF- ABDULLAH BIN SALIM AL SHUEILI

Why do children raised in the same house turn out so differently?

minus
plus

Last weekend I took my four boys camping in the mountains. It was a chance to bond and to escape the noise of the big city for a while. As soon as we arrived, one of them set off on a hike, while another took charge of the barbecue as if it were his natural duty. The next morning, one was up early making tea and watching the sunrise. I could not help noticing that four young men, sharing the same parents and raised in the same house, each had a personality entirely his own.


This made me wonder why children of the same family turn out so differently. Part of the answer comes from behavioural genetics. Researchers tell us that once shared genes are taken into account, siblings often turn out only a little more alike than unrelated people. The family influences that seem to matter most are not those children share, but those experiences alone, what researchers call the non-shared environment. In other words, siblings may share a roof, but they do not share a childhood.


So why should this be? First, children are not passive recipients of parenting. Each arrives with a distinct temperament, and parents respond to it, often without noticing. A calm child draws out patience, while a reactive one may draw out irritation. Some children are also more sensitive to their surroundings, for better and for worse: they struggle more in harsh environments but flourish more in supportive ones. The same household can therefore land very differently on two children.


Second, families assign roles. In many homes, one child, often the eldest, becomes the responsible one, looking after younger siblings or quietly managing a parent’s moods, while another is allowed to remain the baby of the family. Carrying adult burdens too early, sometimes called parentification, has been linked to later psychological difficulties. The child who learnt to read a parent’s face for signs of anger may grow into an anxious, watchful adult, while the sibling who never carried that weight grows up more spontaneous. Neither chose their role.


Third, parents do treat their children differently, whether they intend to or not. A recent study involving more than 37,000 participants found that greater differential treatment within a family was associated with more depression and behavioural problems, with the less-favoured child at particular risk. Another review suggests that parents tend to favour children who are more agreeable and conscientious, simply because they are easier to manage.


This helps explain a scene I meet often in my clinic: adult siblings who remember the same family in completely different ways. One describes a safe and happy home; the other recalls fear or neglect. It is tempting to conclude that one of them is exaggerating. More often than not, both are telling the truth about the childhood they actually lived. A remark one child shrugged off may have wounded another deeply.


So what should parents take from this? Not guilt, but attentiveness. Avoid comparing one child with another; such comparisons rarely motivate and are often remembered for decades. Notice the roles your children have drifted into, and lift burdens that are too heavy for their age. Above all, try to see each child as a separate person, with feelings and needs of their own.


In short, a sibling’s memories need not cancel yours. You grew up in the same house, but each of you had your own childhood.


SHARE ARTICLE
Most Read
AI image
Probation period cannot exceed three months for monthly-paid workers National Day drone shows planned in Muscat, Salalah and Manah Oman, Uzbek sign agreement on new bank, visa exemption, strategic partnership Trucks movement to be restricted on three roads on Friday
FOLLOW US
arrow up
home icon