A friend recently introduced me to a pop-up stall in a Muscat mall with an irresistible promise: some of the world’s best fragrances could be copied for a fraction of their price.
True enough, among the bottles were scents associated with an ultra-luxury perfume house. I knew immediately that they were not the real thing. The fragrance was familiar enough at first, but it did not have the same depth and certainly did not last. Still, for a moment, I understood the appeal.
There is something rewarding about finding an item we thought was beyond our reach and getting a version of it cheaply. It feels less like buying a fake and more like beating the system. We walk away thinking we have found a clever bargain.
Across Muscat, such copies are not difficult to find. They appear as perfumes, watches, shoes, clothes, art and home décor. Sellers may describe them as Class A, AAA, “one-to-one” or “mirror quality”, suggesting an orderly scale from obvious imitation to an almost perfect replica.
But there is no recognised grading system behind these descriptions. No independent body decides what qualifies as Class A or how many As a handbag deserves. They are sales terms, and their meaning can change from one seller to another.
There is also a difference between an affordable product inspired by an expensive one and a counterfeit designed to pass itself off as the original. The first uses its own identity. The second borrows another company’s name, logo, packaging and reputation.
This is where the bargain becomes more complicated. A 2025 OECD report, based on 2021 trade data, valued global trade in counterfeit goods at as much as US$467 billion. Behind that figure are lost sales and taxes, fewer legitimate jobs, weakened businesses and creators watching their ideas reproduced without sharing in the reward.
A European study likewise estimated that counterfeiting costs the clothing, cosmetics and toy industries €16 billion in sales and nearly 200,000 jobs annually.
For consumers, the risks go beyond poor stitching or a fragrance disappearing before lunch. Products made outside regulated supply chains may offer no reliable assurance about their ingredients, safety, or quality. If something goes wrong, accountability can disappear as quickly as the seller.
None of this means that everyone must buy luxury goods. Most of us cannot, and perhaps luxury companies should also ask whether some prices have drifted too far from the value of the product itself. There are excellent affordable alternatives carrying their own names.
A fake may let us enjoy the look, scent, or status of something expensive for less. The attraction is understandable. But the missing amount does not simply vanish. Somewhere along the chain, somebody else pays the difference.
Oman Observer is now on the WhatsApp channel. Click here
